Wednesday, June 27, 2012

NBA Rivalries: Knicks’ Carmelo Anthony versus Heat’s LeBron James


The 2003 NBA Draft was celebrated as one of the best drafts the NBA had seen in a long time even before any players were drafted. That’s because the two biggest names in that draft were current New York Knick Carmelo Anthony and current Miami Heat forward LeBron James.

These two small forwards drafted at the top of the 2003 Draft had different games but both possessed all-world ability. This was supposed to be the second coming of the Bird-Magic rivalry that put the NBA on the map back in the early ‘80s.


Anthony was a flat out scorer. He could drive, post up and shoot with range. Even more intriguing though was how well Anthony performed under pressure.

Anthony played one season at the University of Syracuse before entering the draft. He averaged 22.1 points-per-game during the regular season but it was his stellar play during the NCAA Tournament that showed why he was such a special player as he led Syracuse to its first National Championship.

James never went to college but there really was no need for him to. James had been on NBA scouts’ radars since he was in the 5th grade. Despite only playing on the high school level, scouts could find few holes in his game.

James already looked like an NBA player. He was 6’8”, 250 pounds with a body that looked like it was chiseled out of stone. He was super athletic, could score and rebound but the thing that blew most scouts away was his court vision.

Scouts hadn’t seen a player with his height and passing skills since Magic Johnson retired from the NBA. Although James idolized Michael Jordan growing up, it was believed that his game more resembled Magic’s.

With Anthony’s versatile scoring game and James’s superb mix of size and passing ability, the NBA and the media were really to proclaim this as the next great rivalry. A rivalry that would define the next era of the league and help the NBA finally transition from the Michael Jordan era of dominance.

So what happened? Although Jordan had ended his career for the third and final time just the season before James and Anthony entered the league, there were plenty of other players in the league who were not quite ready to “crown” Anthony and the self-proclaimed King James as the league’s new “saviors.”

Tim Duncan, Kobe Bryant, Shaquille O’Neal, Allen Iverson, Jason Kidd, and a no-name squad in Detroit were determined not to let upstarts James and Anthony reach the Finals as quickly and as easily as Larry Bird and Magic did.

Magic won a championship his first season in the league then went on to win four more before his retirement in 1991. Bird won his first title in his second season in the league and would win two more during his career.

James and Anthony were unable to have the same early success that Bird and Magic had. Anthony played his first seven seasons in Denver and was only able to advance past the first round one time.

James had more playoff success with the team that drafted him, the Cleveland Cavaliers, and was even able to advance to the NBA Finals in just his fourth year in the league. Once there though, his Cavaliers would be swept by a loaded San Antonio Spurs team led by All-Star forward Tim Duncan.

James would be denied another NBA Finals appearance as a member of the Cavaliers though. Two times the Boston Celtics would knock them out of the playoffs and the Orlando Magic did it once.

So in 2010 both Anthony and James decided it was time for a change of scenery. James was a free agent going into the 2010-2011 season and decided he had a better chance at winning a championship playing for the Miami Heat.

Anthony was in the final year of his contract that season and used that as leverage to force a trade to New York. Unfortunately for Anthony the results have been the same. Both seasons he has been in with the Knicks has ended in a first-round ouster.

James once again advanced deep into the playoff and even made it back to the Finals. Once again though, he would be thwarted in his quest for a title. This time by the Dallas Mavericks who were trying to redeem themselves of their previous Finals collapse just five years earlier.

James did get his ring this season but the chances of an Anthony-James rivalry that would match the one Bird and Magic had, never developed and is not likely to. Magic and Bird played in different conferences, on loaded teams and even faced off against each other in the Finals three times.

Anthony and James are now in the same conference which means they will never have the opportunity to play each other in the Finals. And although both are playing on teams that are loaded with talent, Anthony hasn’t been nearly as accomplished player as James has been during the nine seasons they have been in the league.

James has three MVPs, a scoring championship, and now an NBA title. Anthony doesn’t have any hardware of any kind making this once promising rivalry very one-sided.  

And although the Knicks have plenty of talent, they aren’t considered to be in the same class as the Heat. There is still a lot of basketball left in James and Anthony though so there is a chance that this rivalry could get more interesting in years to come but at this point I wouldn’t hold my breath.

 
Do you have a favorite team or player you want to know more about?
Email your questions to sportmentalist@yahoo.com and I’ll devote a post to it. Send your name (or an alias) with the question and get a shoutout on the site.

Want to offer a rebuttal of one of my posts or simply feel you can do better?
Then email your article along with your name (or an alias) and I will post it. 

Roosevelt Hall is an NFL Blogger for The Sport Mentalist and an NBA Blogger for The Sport Mentalist 2. He is also a Sports Reporter for Pro Sports Lives. He can be contacted at sportmentalist@yahoo.com and be sure to follow him on Twitter @sportmentalist.

Also check out these stories:

No comments:

Post a Comment